About Aiello’s

Matts Pizza nyc

Americas Oldest Family Owned and Operated Fresh Mozzarella Company Just Opened a Brand New Authentic Italian Eatery!

Aiello's is proud to open a brand new, family owned and operated, authentic Italian eatery in the Manalapan area. Come to Aiello's when you want to experience first hand the tastiest brick oven and wood fired pizzas available in New Jersey, as well as a variety of other Italian specialties.

The Aiello Family began their tradition of fine Italian cheese making decades ago in Positano, Italy. In 1923 the family decided to bring their tradition to America. The family moved to Brooklyn, New York where they opened a Italian Specialty Market, but the products that stood out the most was their fresh mozzarella and ricotta. The demand grew so much for the families cheese that they formed Aiello Dairy Farms which sold products under the name Aiello Dairy Maid. The families little cheese business turned into one of the largest Italian cheese companies of its time. After years of success the family decided to close the company and keep their Italian markets.

In 1988 Thomas Aiello one of the sons of the owners of Aiello Dairy Farms saw an opportunity in the cheese market for quality cheese products and formed Aiello Brothers Cheese Company with his three sons. They started to make fresh mozzarella the way they were taught by the family and word spread that the Aiello’s were back in business. From making cheese in the back of a small deli Thomas and his sons have grown their small neighborhood business to such a point where they are moving into a 90,000sqft state of the art cheese making facility. Today Aiello’s cheese is distributed all across the nation. The company is still owned and operated by the Aiello Family.

When you come to Aiello's you can expect a quality Italian meal at a great price. Check out all of our specialty pies from our Classic Margarita to our delicious Quattro Stagione. Every one of our paninis is carefully prepared using the finest ingredients available. Stop by or order online ahead of time for pickup. We look forward to serving our community authentic Italian recipes prepared with care.

Restaurant Hours


Location520 U.S. Highway 9 N, Manalapan, NJ 07726 (Closed on Monday)

  • Tuesday 11:00 am – 08:30 pm
  • Wednesday 11:00 am – 08:30 pm
  • Thursday 11:00 am – 08:30 pm
  • Friday 11:00 am – 09:00 pm
  • Saturday 11:00 am – 09:00 pm
  • Sunday 12:00 pm – 07:30 pm